Want to know what the best PC controller is? We’ve tested all the best current game pads to help you make the decision as to which top plug into your gaming PC.
You could argue you’ve already got the best PC controller plumbed into your machine when you’ve got a trusty keyboard and mouse. But, sometimes (and only sometimes) having a specific gaming controller to hand can be quite useful. Whether it’s a great wired or wireless pad, an official or third-party device, having a well-built, comfortable controller can really make the difference to your game. So it’s important you make the right choice.
Pads are great, but it’s also important to make sure you’ve got the best gaming mouse.
We’ve checked out the official Microsoft Xbox One and Elite pads, as well as the excellent Sony DualShock controller. But the likes of Scuf and Razer are still making decent alternatives if you’re looking to peacock with a funky design or just want a host of different buttons at your thumbs’ disposal.
But there are specific controllers for other game genres too. A flight or space-based sim really demands a quality flightstick, especially one with a separate throttle for those BSG Viper-esque, non-Newtonian dogfights. And if you’re a dedicated racer then a steering wheel, with good force-feedback, can shave valuable seconds off your in-game lap times. And may even save your life as I found out…
The best PC controllers are:
Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller
Winner: Best PC controller
Connection – Wired/Wireless | Power: 2x AA | Buttons: 17 | Layout: Xbox
The latest wireless Xbox One pad is sublime. For my money it’s the best PC controller you can buy right now. There may be a growing rank of PC gamers lining up behind Sony’s DualShock 4 as the go-to gamepad, but the ever-so-slightly redesigned Xbox One pad’s got it all.
The overall layout has barely changed from the very first Xbox One controllers, but considering how well conceived and solidly-built they were that’s no bad thing. The balance of the pad in the paw is excellent and curved grip’s comfortable and well machined. Where the new pad has been changed, however, shows Microsoft at their canny best.
The introduction of Bluetooth wireless support is arguably the biggest new thing. No more do you have to go and buy the ugly, awkward official wireless adapter when a standard Bluetooth adapter will do the job. That said, the new Microsoft Wireless Adapter is 66% smaller and a lot prettier… whenever that arrives.
Initially there was an issue with input lag on the PC via the Bluetooth connection, but that seems to have been fixed. Certainly on my ancient USB Bluetooth dongle I experienced no noticeable difference between Bluetooth, wired USB and the MS wireless adapter.
Microsoft has also ditched the proprietary audio connection from the original controllers, allowing you to jam a standard 3.5mm headphone jack into your gamepad, and added a more textured coating to the back to deliver more grip to your sweat-slicked digits.
Then there’s the fact that, because Microsoft is both the Xbox and Windows overlords, once you’re connected to your PC everything works seamlessly. With the Sony pad you need extra software and configurations to make like an erstwhile exterminator and eradicate the bugs. The battery life is impressive and because it uses AA batteries it’s easy to swap them in and out during a sesh, or plug in via USB to keep going while you get them recharged.
The Xbox One wireless controller is a beautifully, ergonomically designed piece of peripheral hardware and it’s tough to see how it’s going to be bettered. For now it’s absolutely the best PC controller out there.
Sony DualShock 4
Runner-up: Best PC controller
Connection – Wired/Wireless | Power: Lith Ion | Buttons: 19 | Layout: PlayStation
PC support for the PlayStation’s DualShock 4 pad is growing, both from gamers and from a technological point of view. Valve have updated Steam to allow full configuration of the DS4 in the same way you can mess with the (frankly rubbish, yes it is… yes it is) Steam controller. That doesn’t, however, mean all Steam games will support it equally though.
To get full support across your games you’ll likely need to use InputMapper to get it recognised as an Xbox pad, but that also allows you to use the trackpad as a mouse and turn off the battery-draining LED on the front.
I still prefer the Xbox pad’s offset layout, and those trigger buttons are horrible, but the actual analogue sticks themselves are hands down the best around. If only we could get an Xbox pad with the DS4’s sticks. Time to get modding…
Nintendo Switch Pro
Runner-up: Best PC controller
Connection – Bluetooth/USB-C | Buttons: 18 | Layout: Xbox
The Nintendo Switch Pro has been made specifically for the diminutive console, but has been given its own Steam profile and can be connected to your gaming PC with either a wireless Bluetooth connection or, if you want to get configured in Steam, via a USB-C cable.
And it’s a quality pad too, feeling solid and reassuringly robust in the hand. The Pro controller feels like a proper pad, made by a proper company with a gaming heritage. The thumbsticks feel good and the buttons satisfying. It’s also got an unprecedented 40-hour battery life via Bluetooth too.
Unfortunately it does suffer for being designed for the Switch because it lacks proper analogue triggers, something that’s important for a growing number of games, and is absolutely vital in any arcade racer that isn’t Mario Kart.
Nvidia Shield Controller (2017)
Runner-up: Best PC controller
Connection – Wired/Wireless | Power: Lith Ion | Buttons: 17 | Layout: PS/Xbox
Okay, it’s not the most beautiful pad around, but it’s a massive improvement over the first, bloated Shield controller. It’s also impressively responsive over the Bluetooth wireless connection too, and integrates brilliantly with Steam’s Big Picture Mode (as does the generally superior DS4 pad).
It’s not as comfortable to hold as either the Sony or Microsoft offerings, but despite the odd, angular looks it doesn’t ever actually feel unpleasant. The bigger issue, though, is that at $60 (£60) it is a hell of a lot of money when the better controllers are significantly cheaper.
Microsoft Xbox One Elite
Winner: Best high-end PC controller
Connection – Wired/Wireless | Power: 2x AA | Buttons: 21 | Layout: Xbox
I mean, yeah, spending this much on a joypad might seem pretty crazy, but the Elite is one seriously beautiful controller. Almost everything about it has been designed to just scream ‘QUALITY!’ in your face, like some peripheral Aphex Twin, Come to Daddy nightmare.
When you lift it from its solid carry case cradle you can immediately feel the weight of technology in your hands. It’s heavy, but not so much that it becomes uncomfortable to hold over a long play session. It’s not just its general heft that makes it a pleasure to hold either, the non-slip coating has a smooth tactile feel, and the buttons and d-pad feel reassuringly solid too.
I’m also in love with the triggers. The adjustable sensitivity is a neat touch, allowing you to set each individually as a hair-trigger, where the travel is reduced only to the initial actuation point, or you can leave the full analogue travel in place. When you’re switching between a shooter or a racer that can be incredibly useful. As can the extra four paddle switches on the reverse. The paddles are magnetically attached – meaning it’s easy to swap them out when you don’t need them – and can be configured to replace any of the other buttons on the controller.
They’re not the only magnetic parts of the Elite either. There are two different d-pads and three sets of thumbsticks you can switch around in an instant. The magnetic attachment is seriously sticky and there’s never a feeling they’re too loose.
Where I have a slight issue with the Elite is those thumbsticks. They’re still not as good as the DS4’s analogue sticks and, on a couple of samples I’ve tested, are even a touch more waggly than the more-rigid standard Xbox One pad. I would prefer they were stiffer, but that still never affects their responsiveness in-game.
It’s beautifully built, impressively responsive, and ultra versatile too. But I’m still not 100% sure that it’s worth that hefty a price premium over the standard Xbox One controller, which is why the Elite isn’t down as our absolute, must-have, best PC controller in this test. Money-being-no-object though, it would be the Elite every time, but it is such a lot of cash.
Scuf Gaming Impact
Runner-up: Best high-end PC controller
Connection: Wired/wireless | Power: Li-Ion | Buttons: 22 | Layout: PlayStation
But you do also get a whole bunch of paddle switches on both the Impact and the Infinity 1 controllers. They’re solid, and require quite a bit of force to actuate, but that means you won’t end up hitting them by accident. And they also come in designer threads too. Shiny.
But they’re also the most expensive pads we’ve checked out so far. The Golden Dragon version especially – and you really are paying over $200 for the privilege of sweating over some fake dragon scales. The fancy colours and the paddles switches are the only things which mark these controllers out from the competition. But if you want to peacock with your pad, then Scuf will have you covered.
Razer Wolverine Tournament Edition Chroma
Runner-up: Best high-end PC controller
Connection: Wired | Power: USB | Buttons: 20 | Layout: Xbox
The Cult of Razer… from its Texas compound… has obviously taken one look at the Xbox One Elite controller and said, we can do better than that. It can’t. It’s added in some extra microswitched buttons to the Wolverine, some adjustable hair-triggers, dropped in a pair of pseudo paddle switches on the underside of the pad and kept it otherwise very clean. Unlike the green-tinged Wildcat below…
But it’s still a wired controller, which costs around $120, and still only really feels on a par with Microsoft’s standard pad. There’s nothing really wrong with the Wolverine, but there’s equally very little that makes it stand out from the crowd. Well, apart from the RGB LEDs of course…
Runner-up: Best high-end PC controller
Connection – Wired | Power: USB | Buttons: 21 | Layout: Xbox
The Wildcat is Razer’s previous response to the brilliant Xbox One Elite, but just falls short of the quality of the Microsoft pad. It has extra configurable buttons on the underside of the controller and around the detachable USB cable, with two profiles allowing you to switch and configure on-the-fly. It also has adjustable triggers, with variable travel and actuation points.
Razer has recently launched the new Wolverine Ultra as a more direct competitor to the high-priced Elite, costing $160 (£149) but we haven’t yet had a chance to see how they’ve improved on either Microsoft’s design or their own.
Where the last-gen Wildcat goes a little further than the Elite is in the additional audio controls which let you adjust voice comms and master volume from the pad when you’ve got a headset plumbed directly into it. Sadly, it’s a resolutely wired controller, which does negate some of the benefits of routing your headphones through your pad. I also think the ultra-low travel A,B,X,Y buttons are a little too quickfire – I found myself hesitating, unsure whether it had registered my click as there’s little tactile response.
And then there are the optional Razer green rubber grips, which you’re never, ever going to be able to fit properly no matter how grippy the bumpy ping-pong paddle rubber is.
Easy SMX Wireless
Winner: Best cheap PC controller
Connection – Wireless 2.4GHz | Power: 2x AA | Buttons: 17 | Layout: Xbox
The Easy SMX Wireless is proof positive you don’t have to spend a fortune to get a well-built PC gaming controller. Sure, it’s losing some of the finesse of the other, more expensive pads, and is more aping the original Xbox 360 controller than the modern Xbox One version, but it’s got a decent battery life and the wireless connection is solid.
It’s also an absolute bargain, even if the triggers maybe don’t feel quite as accomplised as you might want them to be. But it’s still a solid, reliable controller that doesn’t cost the earth, and you can’t really ask a lot more than that.
Winner: Best PC flightstick
HOTAS: Yes | Programmable buttons: 22 | Hats: 4x 8-way, 2x 4-way | Z-axis – No
Thrustmaster’s Warthog flightstick is a replica of the controllers in the classic A-10 Tankbuster, seemingly hewn from the same military-grade materials, and probably only slightly cheaper than a second-hand plane. Yes, the Warthog is frighteningly expensive, but if you’re already looking to pick up a dedicated flight-sim joystick then you’ve probably got pretty niche tastes – and this is the best way to satisfy them.
The HOTAS acronym stands for ‘hands-on throttle and stick’ and means there’s discrete controls for each that ensure you never have to remove your hands from either during combat. Both throttle and stick are festooned with buttons, triggers, and hat-switches as well as the most satisfying flick-switches ever mounted on a PC peripheral. For the serious flight/space-sim aficionado those extra buttons will come in handy – the multi-positional switches almost seem purpose built for Elite: Dangerous.
And I’ll give up my heavily upgraded Cobra Mk III if you can name me another, weightier controller (without checking out the Fanatec steering wheel below). The throttle alone weighs about the same as my car and you could easily kill a man with the stick.
But forget about the weight and the myriad buttons and switches – the action on the throttle and stick are almost worth the sticker price alone. The stick feels sublime, with just enough resistance to make tight docking manoeuvres easy and with enough travel to give you an edge in a dogfight. The split throttle is immensely satisfying to use too – it also has an impressively long travel, giving you both fine grain control over your speed and the ability to do the whole Maverick ‘feel the need for speed’ thing as you push it to the limit right in to the danger zone.
The Warthog has been around for a while now, but I’ve still seen no other flightstick come close to the feeling I get when using it. It’s a lot of money, but still manages to feel worth it when you’re hurtling through an asteroid belt, flipping on a pirate, and reducing their ship to tiny bits of melty scrap. That said, I’m still keen to see what Logitech does with the Saitek brand in the future, then we could see some real flightstick-y competition.
Winner: Best PC steering wheel
Rotation: 900° | Pedals: 3 | Buttons: 17 | Adjustable pedals: Yes
Sooo, yeah… the Fanatec Clubsport setup is the price of a powerful gaming PC, but it is also the stuff of gaming peripheral dreams. NSFW dreams. I mean, this is serious tech pr0n stuff right here, and it’s all down to just how beautifully designed, created, and finished the Clubsport kit is.
If you don’t go for one of the pre-configured bundles you’ll have to create your own, picking and choosing from a very long list of goodies. The main wheel base is the same across the board, but then you can fit different steering wheels, gearshifts, and pedals to the mix. And they’re all built out of solid lumps of metal and precision-engineered components. The tactile sensation you get from using them in-game is second to none. The wheelbase is called “a masterpiece of Germaneering,” on the Fanatec site and they even claim to have a registered trademark on their own little Teutonic portmanteau there, but I’ll forgive them that because the action on this thing is glorious.
It has a full 900° rotation, giving you a huge amount of travel between opposite locks and a super smooth transition between them. Well, depending on the force feedback that is. The Fanatec system has hands-down the best force feedback system I’ve ever used, even down to feedback from the pedals, too. Racing around in Project CARS I began to really understand my cars and the tracks I was hurtling around, even down to knowing exactly where the potholes were and the traction limits of my chosen tyres.
I would question why anyone at all would even consider plugging this stunning bit of hyper-expensive kit into an Xbox One, but for the well-off racing nut the Fanatec Clubsport system has me running out of superlatives.
Runner-up: Best PC steering wheel
Rotation: 1080° | Pedals: 2 | Buttons: 15 | Adjustable pedals: Yes
When it comes to the more realistically-priced racing wheels it’s a toss-up between Thrustmaster and Logitech. The T300RS isn’t Thrustmaster’s most expensive option, but it is still a fantastic wheel nonetheless. It might not have the faux-luxury, faux-leather of the G920 or G29 Logitech setups, but in terms of its force feedback Thrustmaster has just about got them pegged. I do prefer the pedals of Logitech, but it’s the racing feel you want from a good wheel and that’s why the T300RS crosses the finish line just ahead of them.
- SteelSeries Introduces Nintendo Switch Optimised Arctis 3 Bluetooth Headset
- The new Microsoft Xbox Elite Controller is all about that Stormtrooper-chic… and I’ve got to have it
- Hori Releases PS4 Mini Wired Controller
- SCUF PS4 Vantage Controller Announced; Features Xbox-Like Asymmetrical Thumbsticks
- Microsoft Announces New Xbox One X Robot White Special Edition Fallout 76 Bundle; New Elite Controller and Headset Announced As Well